Chocolate Banoffee Pie

Chocolate Banoffee Pie
Chocolate Banoffee Pie

My Gooey, Dreamy Chocolate Banoffee Pie

Hey friends! So, I have a major weakness for desserts that combine a bunch of different textures. Creamy, crunchy, sweet, a little salty… it’s just the best. This Chocolate Banoffee Pie is my latest obsession, and it’s honestly a showstopper. It might look fancy, but I promise it's totally doable. Let's get into it.

The Unforgettable Crust

We're starting by ditching the traditional graham cracker crust for something with a bit more personality. Trust me on this. You'll blitz up some chocolate digestives and salted crackers into fine crumbs. The secret weapon? Browning the butter before you mix it in. It gives this deep, nutty flavour that is just incredible.

  • Sight: A dark, speckled, sandy texture that packs together perfectly.
  • Smell: Rich, buttery, and chocolaty with a hint of salt.
  • Touch: Sticky and crumbly – use damp hands to press it into the tin without a mess!
  • Taste: Seriously, try not to eat this raw mixture by the spoonful. It's a test of willpower.

The Heart of the Matter: The Toffee

This is where the magic happens. You melt together butter and brown sugar, then stir in a whole can of sweetened condensed milk. You just stand there, stirring over a medium-low heat, watching it slowly transform from pale yellow to a glorious, thick, golden toffee. The vanilla essence at the end just sends the aroma through the roof. Let this cool until it’s just warm—this is key so it doesn’t make the bananas soggy.

The Grand Assembly

Once your baked crust has cooled, it's time to build your masterpiece. A light smear of toffee, a layer of sliced bananas, a generous pour of more toffee, and then—if you're feeling extra—another layer of each! The final step is the long chill in the fridge. This sets everything and makes it sliceable.

The Finishing Touches

Right before serving, I top it with clouds of vanilla whipped cream and these easy, homemade dark chocolate shards. Don't worry about making them perfect; the rustic, broken-up look is what we're going for. They add a wonderful bitter chocolate contrast to the sweet, creamy pie beneath.

This pie is a labour of love, but every single second is worth it. The combination of the chocolatey-salty base, the unbelievably good homemade toffee, the fresh banana, and the light cream is just… *chef's kiss*. You have to try it!

Published at: September 20, 2025